241 Fenimore Street, New York City, NY 11225

Create Your Dream Home in Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Welcome to 241 Fenimore Street, a legal two-family, three-story townhouse in the heart of Prospect Lefferts Gardens. Built in 1920, this Colonial Revival gem spans over 4,500 square feet, offering a rare opportunity to restore and personalize a historic home with minimal updates needed.

From the covered front porch to the stained-glass windows and grand wooden staircase, this home is filled with early 20th-century charm. The spacious formal living room features hardwood floors and a decorative fireplace, leading seamlessly into a large dining area and a sun-drenched rear living space. The country-style kitchen, complete with a vintage O’Keefe & Merritt stove, opens onto a deck and serene private garden—perfect for relaxing or entertaining.

On the second floor, you'll find an additional eat-in kitchen, an oversized primary bedroom with bay windows, two more bedrooms, and a full bath. The third level offers three additional bedrooms, another full bath, and an attic space that can be reimagined as a walk-in closet or extra bedroom. The finished lower level includes a separate living area, bedroom, full bath, and coffee nook—ideal for extended family, guests, or rental income.

Situated just south of Prospect Park, this home offers the perfect blend of urban convenience and historic charm. Stroll through tree-lined streets and enjoy easy access to neighborhood favorites like Camillo and PLG Coffee House & Tavern. With Wholesome Foods Market and Lincoln Market just blocks away, everyday conveniences are at your doorstep.

With its historic character, expansive layout, and endless potential, 241 Fenimore Street is your chance to create the home of your dreams in one of Brooklyn’s most sought-after neighborhoods.